basic case

This is the basic "attach to your belt" case for a palm treo shaped device.

One complaint is that it can come off your belt fairly easily. My palm has not yet broken when this happens, nor has it dropped into water or snow. But the potential is there. So you need to be careful when wearing it.

The second complaint is that the case provides no protection for your stylus. My stylus has fell from the palm several times now. So far it fell in my home or office, where I later located it. But eventually it will fall while "out in the world" and that will be it.

For the price paid, not bad. But it's nothing special.

Not what I expected
I expected this to have a pocket on the inside as mentioned in several of the reviews. Also there is logo on the outside which is also unexpected based on the picture.

Treo Pouch works well
I am very happy with my pouch. The only criticism I have is that the shipping was little high. I paid 4.99 for the pouch and 4.99 for the shipping. I think the shipping could have been 50% less.

Somethings get better with age - this doesn't
I owned one of these previously, and was very happy with it. It lasted about eighteen months before the leather around the clip finally began to tear, making the clip's hold on the case tenuous at best. So I gladly bought a replacement.

At first glance, the new pouch looks the same. The problem with the clip tearing away from the pouch has been addressed - that part of the case has been reworked and reinforced with a thicker piece of leather - you can now slide the case onto your belt instead of clipping it to your belt.

The case seems a little larger that the original - My Treo seems to slide a little from front to back. The interior of the case still has a snapped cover concealing storage compartments for three memory cards. In effect, the case is functionally the same as the original one I had.

But you know, I finally figured out why I don't like it. It seems cheaper that the original one. The interior is made out of some kind of fabric and there's a puffy feel to the leather exterior, almost as if the leather is sown on top of a cushion. The original one seems more expensive, more luxurious, by comparison.

In short, the case is functional, but its not as good as the original version of this product was. However, ots still better than anything else I've found on the market to date.

Treo 650 Carrier
I am very pleased with my Treo holder. It clips securely to my belt and my phone is easily accessible.