Fantastic, amused, Fiona...
Musically pretty. Fiona has been experimenting with her own music, creating new sensations and illusions; this is just a step further.

A sad sad decline
Well it was an obvious path to musical collapse, she should have stopped at Tidal. If I'd been dating her for the talent she showed on her first CD I would have broken up with her over this piece of haggis. The course of the last three CD's drew a trendline right from stardom into a melodic pit. The lyrics on Extraordinary Machine were not only not up to their namesake but worse than the melodies. The number of great reviews on this site only go to prove once again the masses prefer pablum in lieu of something complex and cognitive.

Her original Cd with it's collection of diminished and augmented chords set to deep overlays of texturing, blended with truly poetic lyrics has been replaced with a distilled musical joke. What on earth gave her the impetus to try to go 'artsy' by experimenting with music predating the second world war I'll never know. It's obvious her angst is no longer producing art, rather it is being replaced with contrived resolution and the equivalent of a musical epitaph.

Eat it up people, it's all about not having to think. It's the kind of tripe that happens when someone is trying to hard to think of how to outdo their first brush stroke of genius and is confronted with musical block. Judging by the news her father is ruining her life and creativity as so often is the case in todays less than feminine half of the culture.

a great follow-up to when the pawn...
excellent record...
just like a great wine goes well with great food, this is an excellent follow-up to when the pawn (to me her masterpiece) ... listen to her previous album before this one to get the whole picture... excellent, very weird record... fiona is getting even more radical.. and shows she really is one of the best artists of the decade...

One of the best albums of all time
Ms. Apple's talent for consistently brilliant songwriting is staggering. This is a must-have for anyone fascinated by the blurry line between intellectual exploration and raw emotional experience.

A Highly Biased (but still arguably fair, right?) Review From an Avid Fan
I was showing up at stores weeks before this album came out asking if it had come out yet. Yep. I was that annoying girl tapping you on the shoulder and asking, "Well, when should I come back do you think?"

I'm all about Fiona Apple.

And I'm all about this album.

This was also the first dual disc I bought. It was a serious act of restraint on my part to wait for the dual disc to be available to me. I was VERY curious about this new fangled technology and wanted all the Apple my sorry buck could buy.

I was amply rewarded for my patience. The DVD components are spectacular. This disc was in my DVD player for several months. I'd rotate it out when I was going to watch a movie, but as soon as the movie was up, Fiona would be back in her place. I keep the jewel case on top of my television whereas all the lowly mere *music* discs are relegated to the top of my stereo. Oh yes. It's good. REALLY good.

The music is brilliant and broody and as lyrically lovely as ever.

"And it doesn't seem fair
that your wicked words should work in
holding me down
No, it doesn't seem right
to take information;
Given at close range;
For the gag, and the bind, and
ammunition round"

She's haunting and vulnerable and strong and moving and sincere and how can you *not* love her for it?

On the DVD side she covers seven songs in a small ill-lit club including a kick-arse rendition of "Fast as You Can" featuring Chris Thile from Nickel Creek on mandolin. Beautiful. I found myself wanting those songs on the CD side as well because they were so well done.

To all Fiona fans: how can you NOT have this album? Buy it. Fast. As. You. Can.