OK for a start
There is a significant difference between this (their first album) and the subsequent release: "Shadows Are Security." Overall, FWC is ok, for a start. (You have to cut them a little bit of a break since this was their first album). The only people who give this 5 stars are probably already raving AILD fans. Yes, there are a couple cool tracks but not enough to carry the album.

If you're new to the band (or new to Metalcore), don't start with this record. "Shadows Are Security" and "An Ocean Between Us" are both MUCH better.

Not recommended (unless you're already an AILD fan).

pure raw brutality
This album along with shadows are security is one of the best.As i lay dying is a great band the drumming is so freaking amazing some of the best ever,and tim's vocals are pure raw power throaty screaming stuff.If you like them you will love this every damn song is perfect and keeps me headbanging all the time.Stop with the metalcore hate many bands are awesome while others are just "hardcore" and not metal at all so admit it's one of the heaviest stuff out there.So get this album it's loud,heavy,fast,brutal,and amazing it has melodic death metal too so enjoy this great stuff!

As I Lay Dying - Frail Words Collapse
This was the first album I ever purchased from As I Lay Dying, and I enjoyed it immensely. Upon repeated listens I found myself skipping over a few tracks and just repeatedly listening to a half dozen or so. I found many excellent songs on this disc that I absolutely love and few that were instantly forgettable. All in all however, this was a very solid release.

As I lay dying is Metalcore
Basically as I lay dying laid out the blueprint for metalcore with the swirling melodic guitar riffs and the timely palm mute chugs which arent over done.
Favorite songs are as follows
Collision - insane hooks, short and sweet
Elegy - Nice high pitch riffs mixed in with the thumping drums
Forever - excellent riffing again with a brilliantly timed melodic
background chorus.
94 hours - once again nice riffing

All the songs in this album have an energetic feel with raw power and melody.
Great album

As I Lay Dying: Frail Words Collapse
The songs rock my brain. All the tracks were awsome. So Heavy!